Brookville Home Care

    150 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771

    Compassionate Reliable Trustworthy In-Home Care

    I hired this agency for my mom and have been very pleased - compassionate, respectful caregivers who became companions and provided attentive, home-like care. Administration and office staff were professional and responsive, easy to reach, and kept scheduling reliable and flexible; aides were punctual, helpful with driving/housekeeping, and problems were resolved quickly. Overall I'm very satisfied and would highly recommend their caring, trustworthy team.

    Loved one of client
    May 2026

    Services

    • Home Health Care

    Reviews

    4.65·(34)

    Overall rating

    1. 5
    2. 4
    3. 3
    4. 2
    5. 1
    • Caregivers

      4.7
    • Communication

      4.6
    • Reliability

      5.0
    • Scheduling

      4.9
    • Value

    Pros

    • Compassionate caregivers
    • Skilled, well-trained aides
    • Consistent caregiver assignments
    • Responsive office and administration
    • Flexible and reliable scheduling
    • 24-hour care availability
    • Personalized care planning
    • Strong caregiver-client relationships and companionship
    • Prompt issue resolution
    • Care coordination with nurses and social workers
    • Housekeeping and home-support services
    • Caregiver transportation to appointments
    • Home-like private residence option

    Cons

    • Variable caregiver conduct and professionalism
    • Inconsistent complaint handling and incident response
    • Staff turnover affecting care stability
    • Administrative professionalism concerns
    • Variation in care quality across assignments

    Summary of reviews

    Overall impression: The aggregated reviews portray an agency with many strengths in hands-on caregiving and family-facing services, alongside a smaller but important set of operational concerns. Numerous families emphasize compassionate, skilled aides who build meaningful relationships with clients and provide reliable day-to-day assistance. These strengths are frequently paired with prompt administrative communication and an ability to arrange flexible schedules, including 24-hour coverage and transportation support.

    Caregiver quality: Many accounts characterize caregivers as kind, patient, and well trained. Reviewers commonly note that aides serve not only as practical caregivers but also as companions who engage clients socially and provide emotional reassurance. Several reports reference nursing and social-work involvement, suggesting an ability to coordinate clinical and psychosocial supports. At the same time, there is evidence of variability in individual caregiver performance; some families experienced conduct and professionalism issues that are inconsistent with the otherwise positive descriptions.

    Communication and management: The agency's office staff and coordinators are repeatedly described as responsive, reachable, and helpful with scheduling and problem resolution — specific praise is given for quick attention to concerns and accommodating schedule requests. However, there are also statements describing unprofessional interactions with leadership or administrative staff and examples where serious concerns were not handled to a family's satisfaction. These contrasting impressions point to generally effective front-line communication but uneven management responses in higher‑stakes situations.

    Reliability and scheduling: Reviews emphasize reliable shift coverage, punctual caregivers, and flexible scheduling, including aides who can drive clients and options for 24-hour care. Long-term continuity — in some cases five years of the same caregiver — is cited as a major strength. Conversely, mentions of staff turnover and variable assignment quality indicate that continuity is not uniform for all clients; prospective families should confirm specific scheduling and continuity commitments for their case.

    Value and notable patterns: Families frequently report peace of mind, prompt attention, and services that extend beyond personal care (housekeeping, home-cooked meals in a private-residence option, and open visiting policies). These elements contribute to perceived value and client satisfaction. The notable negative pattern is operational variability: isolated but serious conduct concerns and inconsistent incident resolution have been raised alongside glowing endorsements. That combination suggests a generally strong service with occasional lapses that can have outsized impact on trust.

    Practical takeaway: For prospective clients and families, key due-diligence steps are recommended: ask about caregiver screening and training, clarify continuity guarantees and backup staffing plans, request the agency’s formal complaint and incident-response procedures, and obtain references for specific caregivers when continuity is important. Those steps should help maximize the agency’s evident strengths while mitigating the operational variability some families experienced.

    Location

    Map showing location of Brookville Home Care

    Brookville Home Care is located at 150 South St, Oyster Bay, NY 11771.

    People often ask...

    Disclaimer

    Mirador Home Care is not affiliated with the owner or operator(s) of Brookville Home Care. The information on this page is provided as a public resource and may not reflect the most current details. For exact information, please contact Brookville Home Care directly. There is no cost for using this service.

    Nearby Home Care Agencies

    Home Care in Nearby Cities

    1. 1 agencies
    2. 0 agencies
    3. 0 agencies
    4. 0 agencies
    5. 0 agencies
    6. 0 agencies
    7. 0 agencies
    8. 0 agencies
    9. 0 agencies
    10. 0 agencies
    11. 0 agencies
    12. 0 agencies
    Mirador

    Helping families find trusted in-home care services. Your guide to quality home care.

    Company

    Home care services

    © 2025 Mirador Home Care